• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Tony's Pizzeria - Herkimer: Authentic Thick-Crust Pizza with Generous Toppings

Tony's Pizzeria - Herkimer, located at 435 Mohawk St, offers a standout pizza experience with its thick, chewy crust that balances lightness and crunch. Unlike typical NYC thin crusts, Tony’s style embraces hearty, generous toppings—from savory sausage and pepperoni to fresh veggies and rich ricotta. Customers praise the well-seasoned sauce and satisfying cheese layers, creating robust, flavorful slices. The inviting yet simple atmosphere suits both dine-in and takeout. Whether finishing a bike ride on the Empire State Trail or stopping by for a quick meal, Tony’s delivers consistently delicious, comforting pies that leave a lasting impression. A true gem in Herkimer.

Tony's Pizzeria - Herkimer at a glance

  • Address 435 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY 13350, United States
  • Phone +1 315-866-4593
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Tony's Pizzeria - Herkimer: Reviews & Ratings

John Marino
5

The pizza it's delicious. I had 3 slices 1 upside-down sausage 1 everything. All very tasty

Jay Johnson
5

After a day of riding the Empire State trail we were ready to EAT. Tony’s Pizzeria was recommended by our hotel staff and we were very very pleased by the quality of their pizza and salads. This was not your super thin crust NYC pizza but instead had an amazing thick chewy crust with completely generous toppings and cheese. Highly recommend Tony’s…GRAZIE, Tony!!!

Carlos Fernandez
4

Address in Yelp seems wrong but found via Google. Good thing we did because the pizza was very good. Crust was nice, thick but light and crunchy, a la Sicilian pan pizza but not square. Fresh veggies, sauce wasn't too sweet or heavy and ok cheese (maybe a little bland). Great little road trip find.

Space Ghost
5

Visiting from Chicago. I ate here because it was SO HOT outside I didn't want to walk far from my hotel. It was unbelievably good. I tried a slice they had already sitting there and it was so good I ordered a whole pizza. I had an unusual pizza with hamburger,sausage,cherry tomatoes,jalepeno and a lot of ricotta cheese! It's among the best I've ever had anywhere. Cool people working there too. The dining atmosphere is plain Jane and nothing to write home about, but most folks were just getting it to go. This is really really good!

R H
5

While staying In Herkimer,NY for a night i decided to try this pizzeria on the advice of the desk clerk at my hotel and her advice was correct Tony's Pizzeria makes a great pizza and there garlic bread is very good also. The pizza is what i would call a thick crust but not pan style. I ordered a small pepperoni and sausage with extra cheese and an order of garlic bread. I got it to go, but the pizzeria looks like a great place to eat in at with plenty of seating. My pizza and bread took about 20 minutes, and It was ready to go back to the Red Roof Inn with me.

Kitty Neil
5

In the middle of a roadtrip we stopped off strictly because the reviews were awesome. Man, so glad we did!! I got the chicken cesar salad and the garlic pizza. These portions lasted me for like 3 days!! Service was so attentive and they are experts at what they do. It was clean for the most part, but right before closing so I figured no biggie. The bathroom was very decent. Prices are reasonable and you're supporting a small business so why not. Will visit again when in the area!

Michael Sayer
5

Friendly service in a locally owned business. Pizza is delicious! Pan style, toppings to the edge. Really tasty pizza! We stop here when driving between Boston and Western NY. Well worth a quick stop off the highway.

Location

  • Tony's Pizzeria - Herkimer
    Tony's Pizzeria - Herkimer
    435 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY 13350, United States Hotline: +1 315-866-4593

Tony's Pizzeria - Herkimer stands out as a beloved local gem on Mohawk Street, serving up hearty, satisfying pizzas that capture the spirit of traditional Italian-American cuisine. Nestled in the heart of Herkimer, NY, this pizza restaurant is known for its thick, chewy crust that balances lightness and crunch—far from the thin, foldable slices of NYC yet equally memorable.

The menu’s highlights showcase a careful blend of classic and inventive flavors. The Pepperoni Pizza arrives generously topped, bursting with savory, slightly crisped pepperoni that complements the rich tomato sauce and ample melted cheese. The Sausage and Mushroom Pizza offers a robust pairing, where earthy mushrooms meet well-seasoned sausage, creating a comforting, layered experience. For those seeking something unique, the Philly Cheese Steak Provolone with Onions and Mushrooms is a standout, combining tender meat and caramelized vegetables beneath gooey provolone cheese. Equally compelling is the Sausage and Pepper Sub, which delivers bold, savory flavors wrapped in soft bread—perfect for a hearty lunch.

Customers repeatedly praise Tony’s for the freshness of its ingredients and the quality of its dough. Reviews reflect a consensus that the crust is the star here—thick but never heavy, striking the right balance between Sicilian-style pan pizza and a traditional pie. The toppings are generous, not sparing on cheese or hearty fillings, while the sauce strikes a pleasant balance, avoiding excessive sweetness. Garlic bread, often mentioned as a tasty side, rounds out the meal with its golden, buttery aroma and crisp texture.

What makes Tony's special is not only the food but the welcoming, no-frills atmosphere and the genuine passion evident in each slice. Whether stopping by after exploring the Empire State Trail or seeking a comforting dinner, visitors find a reliable, satisfying option. The community-driven vibe, paired with hearty, flavorful pizzas, ensures that Tony's Pizzeria leaves a lasting impression that invites many to come back for more.

In sum, Tony's Pizzeria - Herkimer offers more than just a meal—it delivers a genuine taste experience where crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings merge into memorable comfort food. For anyone craving authentic, generously topped pizza with character and warmth, Tony’s is a must-visit spot in Herkimer.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards